Today SIYE has its 17th birthday. I would like to take this opportunity to nominate the very first SIYE story as the next Buried Gem.
Unfortunately, the story with SIYE story-Id #1 is gone a long time ago. If anyone here still remembers the story, please let us know and tell us about it.
The story with SIYE story-Id #2 is Can not Stop Loving You by LaArpista.
Unfortunately, this story was left incomplete after 12 chapters and therefore does not qualify as a Buried Gem.
The oldest completed story on SIYE and therefor the Buried Gem 07-2019 is the story with the story-Id #3, published in August 2003.
My Best Guarded Secret by Amanda SaturnVenus
Summary: Ginny writes a letter to Harry on the day he finishes at Hogwarts.
Oh, and by the way, story #4 is the sequel to My Best Guarded Secret. Both stories together are only 2.000 word long. So, if you have 5 minutes, give it a try.