Reviews For The Seventh Horcrux
Reviewer: potternut190 Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 05:23PM Title: Secrets Unravelled Great! I look forward to the next chaper. Reviewer: musicsteph Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 05:21PM Title: Secrets Unravelled YEAH---- you started a new story. I was addicted to your other stories!
Good start to this one! Look forward to more Reviewer: ander Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 03:18PM Title: Secrets Unravelled I read your Curse / Power stories more than a year ago, but I've liked them a lot.
This story seems on the right track as well... I enjoyed Harry's interaction with Petunia, and his thoughts... You're one of the best at describing how he thinks. The part with Ron at the end was very, very sweet. Keep it up, great work!
Ander Reviewer: Sibling Creature Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 11:45AM Title: Secrets Unravelled An interesting start, I look forward to seeing where you take this.
It will be interesting to see how this situation with Dudley will play out.
I must say I liked Ron's conversation with Harry at the end too.
I'm glad to see you're writing again too. I tend to avoid Post HBP fics, but being one of my favourite fanfic authors, your name caught my attention, so this will now be among the few such that I actually follow. :-) Reviewer: annascott Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 10:48AM Title: Secrets Unravelled Woohoo! Another fic from the fabulous Melindaleo!!! I'm so excited. Interesting plot line with Dudley being a wizard. I also enjoyed Harry's musings on his relationship with Ginny, and Ron's comments were perfect. I look forward to more. Reviewer: mageia Anonymous Date: 2006.02.26 - 09:23AM Title: Secrets Unravelled Thats great.. Officially the first fan fictiıon Ron says ok for harry and ginny breaking up. hahah.. Thanks for it.. and.. when will u update, ha? Reviewer: PhoenixAeternum Anonymous Date: 2006.02.26 - 02:30AM Title: Secrets Unravelled Ah, the return of the goddess--- and with a bang!
I must say that I am truly terrified to see what you will do with a Post-HBP fic, considering your angst-ridden tendencies. Your last multi-chapter efforts were angsty enough, but with the heartbreak that accompanies the ending of HBP, I shudder to think what you'll make us go through.
Regardless of that, you're one of the best authors in fandom, so I will play the part of the dog who's kicked by his master, but keeps coming back for a pat on the head. A glutton for punishment, I suppose I am.
I do hope you don't make this too angsty-- I take that back. I like angst. But when it's Harry/Ginny relationship angst... Oh, it is so very, very painful. So in the name of all things holy or otherwise, please, PLEASE don't torture us. Hard.
But on to the actual review of your chapter:
I like it a lot. Whilst Dudley turning out to be a wizard isn't unheard of, the way you're going about treating it is different from anything else I've read. It is also an excellent-- and very convenient-- way of getting Ron and Hermione in the house with minimal fuss on the Dursleys' part.
I'm really glad you're starting another multi-chapter story, as I tend to shy away from one-shots. You are truly amongst the best in fandom, so I am very, very happy to find that you've thrust another offering upon us.
I impatiently look forward to where you take this. I completely understand your unwillingness to do weekly updates. Before I started writing myself, I didn't really understand it. It didn't seem to take that much time to pound out a chapter, but then I started writing. I completely empathise with your position, I don't think people realise just how difficult it is to get such a large chapter out ever week.
Hopefully your backload of already written chapters will keep us from experiencing a drought from you.
Thank you for returning to us, Melinda.
Sincerely,
Tyler
X Reviewer: fritz42 Signed Date: 2006.02.25 - 10:28PM Title: Secrets Unravelled I was left with such an empty feeling after reading HBP. There were so many things that were left unresolved--Harry breaking up with Ginny, Dumbledore dying, the Trio having to go off to find and destroy the Horcruxes. How was I going to wait 2 years until the 7th book was out? Now I don't have to wait. I have wanted you to do a post-HBP since reading your Harry Potter and the Power of Emotion and the Cursed of the Damned. I was absolutely thrilled when I noted your new story. And speaking of the new story,I loved how you made Dudley a wizard. I always enjoy the angst in your stories--no one writes Harry's thoughts and feelings like you do. I loved the exchange between Harry and Ron about Ginny. I am hoping that you don't keep our favorite couple apart for too long. Can't wait for the upcoming chapters; you have a great start to what I know will be a great story. Reviewer: kat Anonymous Date: 2006.02.25 - 10:22PM Title: Secrets Unravelled yay! ive read your other stories - and was really glad to see this one! it looks GREAT - much much better than the other 7th year ones I've tried to read...I can't wait to read more - thanks! Reviewer: hpiknut Anonymous Date: 2006.02.25 - 10:18PM Title: Secrets Unravelled Oooh, I'm so happy to see you're doing a multi-chaptered story. I love your writing! So Dudley's a wizard? Interesting! I liked the ending of this chapter. Yay Ron! I'm curious to see when you have Harry and Ginny get back together - not too long I hope! I'm hoping Jo gets them together in book 7 by Christmastime. Reviewer: HPFAN35 Anonymous Date: 2006.02.25 - 09:46PM Title: Secrets Unravelled I look forward to many new chapters. Your stories are very good and can't wait for the outcome of this one.
Thanks Reviewer: Louise Anonymous Date: 2006.02.25 - 09:36PM Title: Secrets Unravelled This is wonderful! I loved the idea of Dudley being a wizard and how you linked it back to what Dumbledore said in HBP. There could be many meanings to that statement, and I think that this theory is really clever. I loved the interaction between Ron and Harry about Ginny, so sweet. Can't wait for more, I can see already that i am going to enjoy this story (as I did with all your others). | |||||||
|