|
Reviewer: fresh_pickled_toad Signed Date: 2021.01.17 - 05:00AM Title: Chapter 1
I never really liked the sixth movie, and thought it was a shoddy adaptation of a pretty great book, but the way you put it in was awesome, and made me think of the Half blood price movie with a whole new light!
Reviewer: lamhaat shaw Signed Date: 2012.02.21 - 10:58PM Title: Chapter 1
it was really nice to read, but i HATED HBP movie so much that I can not bring my self to appreciate that movie. who gave warner bros the bloody right to change the story COMPLETELY? death eaters never attacked burrow, ginny never kissed harry in the room of requirement and this movie had absolutely no memories of that elf hockey or that ogden guy who was there to arrest gaunt's son.....
they only picked the teenage romance part of the story and left the other really nice stuff....
well anyways it was written brilliantly, that too only after a single watch.... impressive.
thanks!
Author's Response: Oh, I know what you mean. The movie wasn't brilliant but at the time, I wanted to relive the Harry/Ginny moments nevertheless. Ta for the review.~Soraya~
Reviewer: Crius Signed Date: 2009.08.06 - 01:19PM Title: Chapter 1
Good stuff, excellently written. I think though that you missed a good one in the part where Harry comforts Hermione after she sees Ron kissing Lavender. I think that the part where she asks Harry how he feels when he sees Ginny kissing Dean and he says 'Just like this' (or something like that) after Ron and Lavender have left was one of Daniel Radcliffe's best deliveries in the entire movie, and it is kind of Harry/Ginny even if she isn't there because he's obviously fantasising about her by this point in the movie.
Author's Response: That's true. I might add them on to this fic, or do it separately as another fic. Thanks for the idea.
Reviewer: GoDons Signed Date: 2009.08.05 - 06:20PM Title: Chapter 1
A series of missing H/G moments from HBP, the movie. Very unique approach and a good one. Well done.
Author's Response: I really wanted to watch it again, to kind of make it sink in, if you know what I mean. It took me back to the cinema, in a way. Thanks for your ever positive feedback!
Reviewer: GREYWOLF Signed Date: 2009.08.05 - 09:35AM Title: Chapter 1
Quite nice. You left out the attack on the burrow. I thought that was the moment (in the movie) that they first realised their feelings. By the way, where is the wedding going to be now?
Author's Response: I think the moment in the movie when they first realised their feelings was a tiny bit earlier, when Ron interrupted Ginny feeding Harry a mince pie. I think they realised they liked each other then, and just before the attack on the burrow (that moment) was when they actually wanted to act on those feelings.
About the wedding - I'm not sure. Maybe they're going to change the location completely? Perhaps it'll be in a hall or something, 'cos I saw that Hermione. Ron and Harry were walking out of somewhere, so maybe it's in London. Who knows? They change too much to be honest.
Reviewer: tear_away Signed Date: 2009.08.05 - 09:31AM Title: Chapter 1
Nice... liked all the POV it was good to read. I have to be honest and say certain parts of the movie really disappointed me. The whole Harry/Ginny plot - wel there wasn't enough of them and I didn't like the way the kiss was done (although I thought Bonnie was the best she has ever been). The end of the movie was a maasive let down due to the completely missed out best part of the book. Think of the battle scenes they could have had. Overall I rate it as not as good as OOTP 6/10.
Author's Response: Tell me about it! I didn't like the way that Harry and Ginny didn't even date in the film. It didn't make much sense, especially for non-readers. The kiss was sweet, but would do better as an addition.
I'll be honest, though: I cried at the end of the film! It was good in the sad, melancholy sense, but not in the romantic sense. I would rate it 8.5 out of 10, way better than OOTP - I really didn't like it to be honest - I would only give that 6/10. But anyway, thanks for the comment!
Reviewer: ginny_lola Signed Date: 2009.08.05 - 08:40AM Title: Chapter 1
No Review
Author's Response: Thanks for the top rating! ~Soraya~
Reviewer: mrsradcliffe Signed Date: 2009.08.05 - 08:23AM Title: Chapter 1
Not word perfect to the film, and yo missed out the Burrow Christmas scene. But it was really nice to read!
Author's Response: Thank you! I know it's not word perfect. I tried to get it as close to word perfect as possible, by looking up all the scripts and stuff. And the reason I left out the Christmas scene was because I haven't been able to find any scripts or clips of that particular bit, so it wouldn't even be near word perfect.
