SIYE Time:12:39 on 19th April 2024 SIYE Login: no | | |
|
|
Reviewer: pottermania Signed
Date: 2014.02.03 - 05:30PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
I'm looking forward to the Linny interview although I'm expecting that mr Tavistock might actually succeed in getting this client to keep her mouth shut!
Author's Response: He might, but you’ll have to wait and see.
-N-
Reviewer: potterfan2008 Signed
Date: 2013.03.18 - 08:03PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Excellent chapter, I had to reread a bit. I have to agree with Harry and Neville, but sending one Auror to investigate a werewolf village seems ridicules and totally within canon. I'm glad progress has been made in the investigation and Harry and Ginny are back together. They always do better together.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. The organisation of the wizarding world has always seemed a bit haphazard to me. Harry and Ginny still have a few issues. -N-
Reviewer: decdraft Signed
Date: 2011.01.15 - 03:51PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
So glad I finally went back and starting reading this again! I quit reading after Ginny in the bar - that was sooooo not Ginny, I had a bad feeling about how the story was going to go. Which only goes to show I should have had more faith in your fabulous story telling abilities! So, I am back to reading this again - can't wait for the next chapter. And your OC characters are so great - and how you interweave plots from your other stories is incredible. Loved the reference to Hannah and Neville's New Year's Eve kiss - and finding out why Lavendar is now a werewolf. Great job! Debbie
Author's Response: Thanks for the review The next chapter is now here. The next will have more information about Ginny's behaviour. I will admit that Fenella, for one, has grown from a bit of a joke character in Grave Days to one of my favourite OC's I probably over use her. I have a detailed timeline of major plot events from the Battle to the epilogue and I write my stories around it. this makes interweaving easy and actually allows me to plot stuff around events in other stories.-N-
Reviewer: Emlyn Signed
Date: 2011.01.14 - 08:40PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Glad to see that Ginny is back and things are coming to light. Can't wait to see how this all works out. Luna is priceless, as usual. Tavistock is such an unbelievably huge jerk.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. After the next chapter everything is in chronological order. Luna dispenses more wisdom in two chapters time. In the next, Harry has to rely on Lavender for advice. -N-
Reviewer: Green Eyes Signed
Date: 2011.01.11 - 09:04PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Just wanted to congratulate you on the DSTA! It is very well-deserved. This story is strong confirmation of the adage that you should not judge a book by its cover (or by one of its preliminary chapters). I was really appalled by drunken Ginny hexing kids, so much so that I almost did not read this. Boy, am I glad I did. This has become one of my favorite stories and I really look forward to the updates. As I said, well done.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review and the congratulations. One of the major hazards of reading fanfics (in my opinion) is that it’s often difficult to determine whether the author simply has no grasp of the characters JKR created and is writing them wildly out of character to create a wish-fulfilment fantasy (thankfully many of these stories are handily labelled Dramione (or worse, Drinny) and thus can easily be avoided). Sometimes, however, there is a plot reason for a character to be behaving out of character. Hopefully this story falls into the latter category.-N-
Reviewer: Birlan Signed
Date: 2011.01.11 - 08:15PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
For some reason, I was thinking about this story and realized what a really lousy work environment Hermione has had to put up with in your stories.
In your story on FF.net, DracoM, her boss tries to kill her after marginalizing her and degrading her. In this story, she is sexually harassed by her boss, who also steals Ron's flowers and abuses his authority to try to get Ron out of Hermione's life--and lies about their relationship to everyone including Arthur and Ron.
Then, in your story about Hermione's secret diary, she is sexually harassed by her suboridinate, Blaise and while she is receiving a promotion, her old boss from this story is still around and trying to sabotage things for her.
Does the Ministery of Magic have a Complaints Box or any other mechanism for Hermione to get some relief. Maybe an Human Resources Department or Ombudsman. And if it doesn't, maybe that should be Hermione's next crusade...
Author's Response: You’re right, of course. This is, to some extent, deliberate on my part as I am (very crudely I suspect) trying to show that the Ministry is still institutionally prejudiced. As a workplace environment I’m trying to show it as about 30 years behind the Muggle world. Both “The Secret Diary of Hermione Granger” and “The Girl from D.R.a.C.o. M. C. were originally written (hastily) for challenges on HPFF. They are no longer there, of course, because HPFF operate like the Minitrue and instantly make you an unperson when you’re banned. (You can be warned by the mods simply for mentioning my name.) “Diary” needs (and will eventually get) a complete rewrite. Blaise is completely out of character (in HBP he despises Ginny for being a blood traitor, so he’s unlikely to act towards a Mudblood in the way I wrote). Some people think that Draco is out of character too. I disagree. By the time of “Diary” Hermione has been promoted above Jenkins and that annoys him (I shouldn’t admit this, but he’s based on someone I once worked with). “Diary” came second (out of two entries) in a Draco/Hermione/Blaise challenge. I wrote it as a joke and it failed to meet the expectations of readers of Draco/Hermione/Blaise stories (for obvious reasons). “Girl” is set within Hermione’s first few weeks working at the Ministry, at a time when the Ministry is still full of collaborators (and worse). I was banned from HPFF before this story was judged. It too needs to be rewritten and expanded. In fact the reason I was banned was because I decided to rewrite and expand my Tales of the Battle. After the events of this story Jenkins will get a (very) hard time from Ron (I have vague plans for him). -N-
Reviewer: jennkaye Signed
Date: 2011.01.08 - 12:55AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
I do love a story that keeps me wondering all the way to the end. Even though I concluded that there was bad pumpkin juice and Slytherins involved in Ginny's problems, I am thrilled that there is still so many unanswered questions! And I give you full marks for cryptic clues in your author responses to reviews! : ) I'm also anxious to see the whole connection beyond parallel conflicts--I feel there must be a connection other than the timing. Then there's motives--what is up with Linny (and with whomever was supplying her directly with "special secret ingredient" alcoholic pumpkin juice. A sort of imperius curse in a bottle influencing Ginny to act in ways that are out of character--oblivious to Linny's actions and wanting to "physically and mentally" harm Harry?) You just don't do things like this on a whim. No one would do to a friend what Linny did to Ginny. You may think you've given away too much sometimes, but Linny and her motives remain a wonderful mystery.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. I don’t think that I’ve given you any clues at all to Linny’s motives. Thinking about it, that may have been a mistake. The timing is of some significance, but it’s not critical. You only ask one question, and it’s a very good one so I’m not going to answer it!-N-
Reviewer: Arnel Signed
Date: 2011.01.07 - 01:00AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Somehow, I missed the posting of Chapter Eleven, so I ended up reading both eleven and twelve together, one right after the other. I'm very happy to say that had I stopped at the end of eleven, I would have been quite the anxious reader. However, because chapter twelve ended with the assureance that, though wounded, Harry was alive and breathing, I walked away from the story a little happier than I would have been. I think that's what I like most about this story: throughout the telling you're continually reassuring the reader that the tale doesn't end with Harry's death, but with the reconciliation of Harry and Ginny and the foundation stones for Harry becoming Head Auror some years down the pike.
As for Chapter Eleven, I'm very glad Harry was able to convince Darcia to help Lavender. I also know that in the end, Harry will do his best to keep the promises he makes and he has definitely made a big promise to Darcia to get her and her daughters out of the community and into the Wizarding world.
What I liked most about Chapter Twelve is how calm the law officers are in comparrison to the Harpies' lawyer. They seem to accomplish so much more working quietly and calmly than Tavistock ever will with his bluster and orders for his clients to remain silent and not answer any of the questions. You definitely had me cheering when Harry reached out to Ginny and he was able to bring the fire back into her eyes and the fight back into her being so that she not only declined Tavistock's counsel, but forced him from the room. Go Ginny! Oh... and isn't this the third Trap chapter in a row where Harry has to ask Hamish for the meeting room back? That gave me a laugh. Finally, I love how you write Neville as such a confident wizard. It's nice to see how you interpret Neville growing into his potential.
All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed both chapters and give them each two thumbs up. I'm definitely looking forward to the next chapters as the story winds to its conclusion.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review The “cliffhangers which can’t really be cliffhangers” are an oddity of writing the story in this order. I’ve read a few “Harry/Ginny” stories over the years which are no such thing (some ffnet authors are particularly guilty of this). I added the reassurance because for most of the story things look bad for my hero and heroine and I didn’t want to put off readers. I’m writing my stories based on a single timeline of important life events, and not just for Harry and Ginny. The date Harry and Ginny announce their engagement, Lestrange’s final fate, the capture of Goyle, Bletchley, Bulstrode and Flint, the name of Dudley’s girlfriend, the date of Dennis Creevey’s wedding (and the name of his wife), When Ron and Neville leave the Auror Office and when Harry finally becomes Head Auror, I know all of this and more. My timeline stretches to the epilogue (and beyond) and I add stories to it almost randomly. Dacia and her daughters, as you’ll know from Strangers at Drakeshaugh – though 12 year old Amber and 21 year old Amber are rather different. Tavistock is a pompous bully who expects the fame of his clients to carry more weight than it does with Mrs Quarrell. You’re right about the meeting room, Harry has learned to keep private discussions private. I’ve always been very fond of Neville and I am fighting the urge to write a Neville/Hannah story (because I have too many stories started). Next – The Hunt: Tooth and Claw. In which Harry ponders Auror procedures (again), sees Lavender in her underwear (again) and kisses her. It will make sense when it happens, honest! (-;-N-
Reviewer: hushpuppy22 Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 07:58PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
I'm glad we finally go to this point but I do feel a bit disappointed that Ginny was so easily manipulated and oblivious to Lilly's sabotage and lies.. Ginny may see another better part of Linny than we readers; however, there are so many signs that Linny's not trustworthy such as trying to break up Ginny's relationship with Harry and failing to actually take care of Ginny like she promised. How can Ginny remain oblivious to the fact that the three times she went out and got wasted, she had Pumpkin juice from Linny beforehand? Maybe a normal person wouldn't think anything of this but Ginny has George (and formerly Fred) to train her not to trust food and drink others provide. But she trusted this bitter, vindictive girl with her own safety and reputation. Plus, how can you easily trust someone that badmouths your boyfriend (that your family adores) to the extent Linny did? It seems a bit stupid. But, Ginny's human so maybe I should just go with it?
Author's Response: Thanks for the review.
Every one of your observations is valid and I can see why you could feel disappointed at the end of this chapter. There is still one huge question to be answered. How can you trust someone who badmouths your boyfriend? If you want clues to the answer then:
Look for two things mentioned by Green Eyes in his review, the Auror Office analysis of the pumpkin juice, an observation made by Dacia Skoll, and the wise (and canon) words of Professor Snape.
-N-
Reviewer: skiutahnum1 Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 06:38PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Soon ginny and crew are going to have to kick harry in the balls to get him to listen and work with them...ginny now knows she screwed upa nd soon the third player is going down with lawer in tow...kutgw
Author's Response: Harry knows that he’s screwed up, too. -N-
Reviewer: potterfan2008 Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 04:54PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Yeah! Ginny is back. I'm glad there is a logical explanation for Ginny's behavior. Now Harry needs to discover why Ginny was targeted.
Author's Response: Thanks. You’ll find out more soon. -N-
Reviewer: zeta_one Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 03:21PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Looks like it's all starting to come together. This is a very good story and I'm enjoying it very much.
Thanks for sharing.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. -N-
Reviewer: jojo99 Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 02:46PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Can't wait to read more.
Author's Response: Thanks, that's always good to hear. -N-
Reviewer: Dad Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 01:09PM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
The parallel story line thing! This was such a good chapter I would give you two extra marks over my norm. But because I am biting my fingernails for the resolution of the last chapter, I am taking one back.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. So if I make the next chapter LESS nailbiting, I get more marks? That's a shame, as I want more nailbiting, not less. (-; -N-
Reviewer: curren Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 11:45AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
I love the complex narrative you've created here.. and the frequent updates :)
Looking forward to what comes next
Author's Response: Thanks I hope to update again in a week or so. What comes next? Well, among other things, you'll find out why Harry kissed Lavender. -N-
Reviewer: mwinter Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 11:08AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Hum! Really enjoying this story. Sounds like the four Slytherins got to LInny to get Ginny to get back at Harry. As well as other things.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. You will find iout more soon. -N-
Reviewer: Green Eyes Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 10:49AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Another nice chapter. In fact, one of the most satisfying yet. The one everyone (and by “everyone,” I mean “me”) has been waiting for. I liked the moment where Harry was trying to spur the “real” Ginny back to life. (I know from other writing that you “get” the “real” Ginny, so it has been frustrating to have her so missing in this story.) I feel like we now know about 90% of what we need to know. I am probably sounding like a broken record (kids these days have no reason to know what that phrase means), but I still think that the info we have learned so far would explain why Ginny would get drunk with Linny ONCE, but not more than that. Her statement that she has continued to (unsuccessfully) use the pumpkin juice as stomach liner for weeks just does not sound like Ginny. She is a whole lot smarter than that. Maybe that is all of the answer that there is (i.e., Linny continued to fool her time and again for weeks with the pumpkin juice Ginny thought was safe), but I think there is still more to it. Ginny’s two statements that I am focused on are: “It’s like somewhere in the back of my mind there’s someone who wants to hurt you, physically and mentally” (that’s more than spiked pumpkin juice or alcohol enhancer causing that) AND her first statement “Oh Harry, what has happened to US?” Why did she say US? I would have expected her to say ME. Anyway, I’m loving this story.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. I like the “broken record” comment (-: and I would steal it if it weren’t for the fact that wizards wouldn’t know either! You have picked up on several important points, most of which will be resolved in the next (and last) “Trap” chapter (which will be called Beater Grouses unless I can come up with something better). You’ve certainly picked up on a couple of the clues I’ve left. There was a (very vague) clue given by Dacia Skoll, too. The next chapter is undergoing a final rewrite before I send it to my beta. I really need to complete the final chapters, don’t I? -N-
Reviewer: Birlan Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 09:51AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Very enjoyable chapter. I've liked how you have had the story lines parallel to this point. I've reread them in straight order and it is better with the alternating.
I am now wondering if Linny is linked to the Slytherin 4.
I had noticed how idiotic the one auror rule had been on Harry's investigation. The fact that Neville demonstrated the idiocy as well was unexpected and well done. And that parallel was als a good reason for the story structure.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. The parallel storylines were an experiment. I’ve been rereading this again myself and I’d need to do a complete rewrite if I was to submit it chronologically, as you pick up bits in the “Trap” chapters which are useful in the “hunt” chapters (and vice versa). You won’t have to wonder for long. JKR tells us that Harry reorganises the Auror Office and I have always had the impression that the entire Ministry operates on a “we’ve always done it this way” system and is very resistant to change. That’s what I’m trying to write.-N-
Reviewer: Ginny Guerra Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 08:18AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
I so hate that barrister!
Author's Response: He's only doing his job! -N-
Reviewer: terachan Signed
Date: 2011.01.05 - 06:14AM
Title: The Snare: Legal Lizard
Great story!!! Well done
Author's Response: Thank you. -N-
../back
! Go To Top !
|