SIYE Time:11:28 on 28th March 2024 SIYE Login: no | | |
|
|
Reviewer: BrianMcLyr Signed
Date: 2021.12.17 - 01:12PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
Hiya Manwe. PM's are off-line again, thought I would try through review... srry to hear the other site might have gone down for the count this time, is there an archive of some of the works that were there exclusively? I know a good deal of your's are on ff.net but some of the other 88k reads ? /smile
Reviewer: Bubbles Signed
Date: 2020.12.22 - 09:50PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
What an odd take on post-dh...
First, Ginny is extremely insecure and ooc, and then the Weasleys want to keep Harry and Ginny apart. I find both of those things really unlikely based on the books. Like...why does Mrs. Weasley more worried about Harry and Ginny's relationship than the death of her own son?
Reviewer: I Love Ginerva Signed
Date: 2018.11.03 - 03:44AM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
No Review
Reviewer: BrianMcLyr Signed
Date: 2018.07.16 - 06:03PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
I enjoyed this the first time I read it, enjoying it again. /smile....can't find the damned emogies
Author's Response: Thank you, It won't be exactly the same this time, because I have lost some chapters. I hope you still enjoy it.
Reviewer: skiutahnum1 Signed
Date: 2018.06.15 - 02:55AM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
Well if that was a one shot I say keep it going but could also end and everyone would be satisfied....kutgw
Author's Response: When I posted the second chapter I changed the Story classification, but didn't change chapter 1 description. I have changed it now.
Reviewer: HP18 Signed
Date: 2018.06.12 - 11:47PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
Wow I'm surprised Harry and Ginny are acquiescing to Ginny's family so easily. And shouldn't the Weasley's know after 7 children that the more rules you put on a young couple the more they try to break them
Author's Response: Arthur and Molly feelings and opinions are very important to both Harry and Ginny. But there are limits! Thank you or the review.
Reviewer: ngayonatkailanman Signed
Date: 2018.06.12 - 09:36PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
My goodness. What a treat to read this excellent story.
Author's Response: Thank you, I hope you enjoy the rest of the chapters.
Reviewer: budabobo Signed
Date: 2016.02.11 - 05:39PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
I have read this story on a different site, and is one of my favorites. Harry the Aurorand Ginny the Quidditch Queen, are true to canon. Am having a great time reading Love Enough for Both. I like the alternate uni theme.
Author's Response: Thank you, I am glad you enjoy my stories.
Reviewer: Gin110881 Signed
Date: 2015.05.30 - 04:55AM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
I’m sorry, I didn't want to bad-mouth your story or affront your work. I know that many people at siye will love this story. Ginny is my absolute favorite character in fanfic. Lately I was a bit frustrated by the post-DH and RapeGinny stories, which I have found. Plus, I cannot imagine that the two of them will choose additional years of separation to live for their professions (Auror, Quidditch Queen), and in case of Harry under the control of the Ministry. It also doesn't fit to Harry that he uses his fame to become an Auror without a completed education. That are the reasons why I focus on pre-DH and AU stories.
I was so happy when I found your story and converted it to an ebook, and then I was just a little disappointed that it comes to Aurors and Quidditch again ... and than I wrote my comment, sorry.
On the other hand, if you really plan to write a post-DH story without Auror Harry and Quidditch Queen Ginny, I’ll promise to be a loyal reader. :-)
cu/ Martin
(sorry my pm function doesn't work well. Thats why I send my message this way. Feel free to delete it after you read it)
Author's Response: I understand and respect your reasons. However, those two things aren't the reasons they put their life on hold. With you being a big Ginny fan, You may not like the story, because it focuses on her insecurities and faults more than Harry's.
M.V.
Reviewer: Gin110881 Signed
Date: 2015.05.27 - 10:19AM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
I really liked your version of Ginny's and Harry's reunion. I think Ginny's anger and her reaction are very understandable.
I was very pleased to find the continuation of the story on another page. But unfortunately, when I skimmed through the story, I noticed that two of my nightmares have come true in this story, "Auror Harry" and "Quidditch Queen Ginny".
In those post DH-stories, I've read so far, it was mostly about that Auror Harry has no time for Ginny when she needed him the most. If he has time, Ginny is locked up for weeks in training camps or has to fight with her B-list celeb status in the press. So I promised myself to read such stories never ever again, sorry.
But of course, that does not affect my opinion regarding the first chapter, that I actually liked very much.
Thanks for sharing!
Author's Response: I am glad you enjoyed their little reunion. As I read the rest of the review, I find myself in a strange place of defending my writing on a story that I may complete on this site. I am assuming you found this story on another fan fiction site. Yes, you have Harry becoming an Auror and Ginny pursuing her Quidditch career, but that is background to the real story. The two of them must grow and mature as individuals and a couple. There is separation issues, anger, fighting, and forgiveness, but I don't do endless pages of angst (aka whining).
Now you have me wanting to rewrite this story to complete on this site.
M.V.
Reviewer: _kb_ Signed
Date: 2011.03.13 - 01:06PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
That was very good overall. I can see why you'd want to add a few more chapters. I think what I liked most was that made it realistic. Sure, Harry won, but that doesn't mean that everything is perfectly rosy (pun intended. :) I loved the scene with Ginny explaining how she felt, using the bouquet to help make her, err, point. :) Kevin
Author's Response: Thank you for the review. Yes, there are a few more chapters to go. I will be taking Haryy and Ginny from two teens to two mature leaders in magical England.
Reviewer: tjshelton Signed
Date: 2011.03.07 - 03:24PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
I like where you are going with this and look forward to updates...
Author's Response: Thank you! I hope you continue to enjoy the fic.
Reviewer: DukeBrymin Signed
Date: 2011.03.01 - 04:44PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
Very nice beginning--the fight between Harry and Ginny was good--not too long, with some good humor in it.
I hope that Harry decides to go back to school with Ginny--it would fit with his final statement in this chapter.
Author's Response: Thank you for the review. I am glad you enjoyed the fight between Harry and Ginny. Harry will get to go to school with Ginny, but it won't be in the traditional way. (does that statement have you confused?)
Reviewer: Dad Signed
Date: 2011.03.01 - 12:18PM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
When I started this I thought "TThis has been done before". Then you sprung the all going to Australia bit. Cannot wait for more.
Author's Response: I am glad you are looking forward to more. So many fics seem to be Harry and Ginny vs. The Death Eaters part II, this fic isn't one of those. I have several things planned that I could actually see happening in a post-war scenerio that I haven't seen in other fics.
Reviewer: ngayonatkailanman Signed
Date: 2011.03.01 - 12:10AM
Title: Chapter 1 A New Day
Very descriptive./ You do know how to tell a story.
Author's Response: Thank You!
../back
‘! Go To Top ‘!
|