|
Reviewer: ThatNinjaBrian Signed Date: 2023.06.14 - 12:30AM Title: A Brother's Reaction
Ik this is an old story but gonna review anyway. Ngl I hate Ginny in this fanfic she's acting like some selfish spoiled egotistical brat she's no better then Dumbledore with keeping things from Harry she knew about the prophecy before Harry but yet didn't tell him she's just as much at fault for Sirius death ad Dumbledore. I'm starting to hate Hermione as well keeping all this from Harry we seen what happens when information is withheld in OOTP. Finally I hope Ron does tell Harry and I hope it all blows up in Ginny and Hermiones faces I'll keep reading hoping that happens.
Reviewer: ReaderRabbit Signed Date: 2010.07.13 - 04:43AM Title: A Brother's Reaction
You really are pushing the trust issue and from Harry's perspective it just doesn't fit. Trust isn't the issue for him isn't simply Love. The love of a person that is harmed would do more damage than any lose before.
Reviewer: piltad Signed Date: 2008.04.19 - 10:29PM Title: A Brother's Reaction
Well keeps going down its a boat with holes I think you shouldn't of written any of the whole "We are all fine with Ginny running away going solo and doing god only knows what with deatheaters". Just doesn't fit and you didn't give it enough background I think for it to fit in your story unless this is a squel and im stupidly reading this first you have gone off a JK world to this and its just not lining up you have skill there is no doubt and I don't want to sound like im an ass but this story is still sinking in my mind
Reviewer: Snapple92 Anonymous Date: 2006.06.28 - 02:42PM Title: A Brother's Reaction
Fred and George are so awsome. They sort make me want older brothers, sorta.
Reviewer: TGIF Signed Date: 2006.06.23 - 12:33PM Title: A Brother's Reaction
I love how everyone has such different opinions about this story! Its really stirring up some discussion.
What I think is causing that- and what is making the story work is that this.... Everyone is doing what they think is best with the information that they have. Harry is left in the dark about Ginny (her talent, past, and current situation) and therefore sees her as an underage witch, while feisty, not someone who would be capable for much help (no underage magic/apparating) plus he wants to protect her because he loves her (so disgustingly noble! :) ).
Ginny has been systematically excluded from most things regarding Harry and the war for years. I doubt she that Harry was even learning Occlumency (and if she did know Harry wasn't the one who told her). While someone else made the point of Ginny not being truthful either, so she can't be mad at Harry I see it differently. She was never close enough - though I put most blame on the boys for that - for either to feel the need to share that information. I think up until Harry's 6th year, while not liking the situation she understood why she was kept out of the information loop. It wasn't until they started dating (and broke up) that got her mad. Harry - and ron- never really stopped and looked at Ginny to take her seriuosly as a part of the war. All Ginny wanted was for them to ask and she would have told them. Lord knows she asked Harry many times and he refused to answer.
I could go on for pages, but I won't. It was frustrating to see that Harry wasn't home when Ron barged in. Then he could have heard the news about Ginny without being mad at either Ron or Hermione. This is going to make it interesting now!
Reviewer: Dragen Signed Date: 2006.06.23 - 06:22AM Title: A Brother's Reaction
George is right that Harry would be devastated when he finds ot about Ginny... but Harry will be more devastated when he finds out that Ron and Hermione knew about this and didn't tell him about it...
I think that Ron and Hermione is wrong about this... I know that they don't want Harry to worry about thing... but I don't think that they turly see Harry PoV... he has lost everyone that he loved by Voldemort, it s hard enigth for him to have Ron and Hermione... but at least he tried to protect the that last thing that he loves... why don't anyone see this...
So far as for tursting people Ron, Hermione and Ginny are making it harded for Harry to trust people, as all three of them are hidings things.
And when Harry finds out that Dumbledore give Ginny trainning and not him, he won't be happy at all. As he should have had it, not Ginny, as he needed it more then anyone.
Fey Falyyn... could you answer some of how reviews, as some of us might like to hear what you think of our comments. And on a side note, could you read my story Harry Potter and the Dragon Stones Saga
Reviewer: Comet Moon Signed Date: 2006.06.23 - 05:25AM Title: A Brother's Reaction
LOVE IT
So Ron's finally growing up, and the Twins are their usual insightful self
Look forward to more
Ja ne
Jim
Reviewer: yentila22 Signed Date: 2006.06.23 - 02:33AM Title: A Brother's Reaction
This is getting very interesting. Can't wait to read what will happen next. Good job
