Reviews For Foolish
Reviewer: pottermania Signed Date: 2012.09.18 - 07:24PM Title: Chapter 22 That has to be the saddest piece of writing I have ever read. It's really late and I should be putting the light out but I know I'll never sleep because my heart is so sore and I NEED to read on to hopefully find some light. Awesome writing . Reviewer: Imperator 277 Signed Date: 2012.08.09 - 03:51PM Title: Chapter 22 I just had a thought. Doesn't Harry consider Teddy when he leaves? He is the godfather, how can he leave him? What will Teddy think? How will Andromeda react when he leaves? It will be really sad for Teddy that Harry will be gone. Unless Harry takes them with him, and I do not know if that is possible. I just have to know! There's obviously guilt involved, because he does love Teddy very much, but he's a great need to get the hell out of dodge, so to speak. There's very few things that would stop him from leaving and unfortunately Teddy isn't one of them. He will miss him every single day, but he has to go. Reviewer: codyesh2 Signed Date: 2012.07.27 - 02:57PM Title: Chapter 22 So I just reread your story and picked up on something that could be big. Reviewer: LEJ418 Signed Date: 2012.07.22 - 08:50PM Title: Chapter 22 Ok so I have a few things I wanted to say, thank you for your kind response last chapter. I hope I didn't make you uncomfortable, I just wanted to convey how much this story personally resonates with me. It is not often one reads a piece of fanfiction like that and I feel I owed it to you to tell you what a remarkable job you're doing. My friend is doing much better but it has been a long road. I wish she'd had people in her life like Ginny did. This really was a calm down chapter. No raised voices (except for Ron's b/c he had to be in the other room), no violence, just people trying to pick up the pieces after a seismic event rocked their world. Your long shot missed. Not humanly possible for Harry to be the baby's birth father. The ring and the dreams are also not connected in that way. They each serve their own purpose. Reviewer: I Love Ginerva Signed Date: 2012.07.18 - 10:48PM Title: Chapter 22 Forgive a second review: Reviewer: Green Eyes Signed Date: 2012.07.16 - 11:46AM Title: Chapter 22 A really gripping, emotional chapter. The only question at this point seems to be whether it was tougher to read it or to write it. Like our two protagonists at various points, I have been kind of at a loss for words. For some reason, when I was reading that final scene between Harry and Ginny, I kept thinking of the Billy Bragg lyrics: Their relationship over those chapters became a grand mansion, only the mansion was made of paper-thick tin. The tentative trust they had in one another, which took those twenty chapters to build, shattered with the arguement in the last chapter, where feelings were crushed and lies uncovered. It absolutely can be fixed. Will it be an easy fix? I don't see how it could be. I'd love to know the title of that song. Sounds like it might fit well on the Foolish soundtrack. Reviewer: Emlyn Signed Date: 2012.07.15 - 02:29PM Title: Chapter 22 I made a serious mistake. I read this chapter right before I went to bed. Which totally messed up going to bed. I had to stay up and read other fanfic before I calmed down enough to go to sleep. It made my stomach clench and tears came to my eyes. Totally off topic - glad you like my state. It's wonderful to live in Vacationland. Harry cares very, very deeply for his family and friends. It's one of his defining traits, all the way back to the first book. What appears selfish to you, to Ginny, and to maybe many others may be serving another purpose in Harry's mind. With Harry's reaction, it all goes back to the point where he had finally let himself trust Ginny again. He had asked her point blank at several occassions if the baby was Lionel's and she always denied it. She always lied to Harry. So all that trust he was putting into her was for nothing and he became angry, at that and at the idea of the almost-abortion. He is sorry for hurting her and that was partly about what going to see her in this chapter was, to apologize once he made the decision to join the task force because he knew he probably wouldn't get another chance to in person. My intent is to make you the reader feel like Ginny: constantly confused about her place in Harry's life. I can only imagine the frustration you guys are feeling at his behavior, but it is what it is. There are clues in here about what Harry is thinking, through his actions and through the things he doesn't act on. Hopefully, they'll make more sense at the end. Hermione is an optimist and she's working with rose-colored glasses on. Lionel has a very strong case to make. Reviewer: RedHeadGin Signed Date: 2012.07.15 - 01:10PM Title: Chapter 22 The saddest chapter, their goodbyes - both of them bereft of hope for a future together. Harry thinking it's all an illusion what they felt for each other these couple of months. Ginny didn't denied it, so her chance to convince Harry to stay w/ her & the Snitch was lost :( She couldn't deny it, not at that moment. Ginny's fighting so many battles at this point, all of them with a lot of pressure, and she just didn't have it in her to fight Harry on something that he appeared to believe was true. I loved that moment, too! Maybe one of my top five favorites in the story so far. I'm sure they both would love to start all over again, but do either of them have the strength to tackle something of such importance in their states right now? I don't know. Reviewer: I Love Ginerva Signed Date: 2012.07.14 - 06:29AM Title: Chapter 22 BOO!!! Reviewer: codyesh2 Signed Date: 2012.07.13 - 08:21PM Title: Chapter 22 Harry is perfectly set up to be the hero. I think he will show up in that court room and show who is boss. I think he will call out everyone and collect on the favors that he is owed. However, to do this either Harry or Ginny has to make the move and say that they love each other and are meant for each other regardless of their pasts. I think Ginny will make the first move. I think she will find Harry and her bravery for it will help convince Harry that's she is not just messing with him. I wouldn't be surprised if it was Harry though. He is definitely looking for an excuse not to throw his life away. However, I think Harry has been broken to the point where he can't overcome the fear of Ginny hurting him and is waiting for her to confirm her love for him first. I will say again, Harry is not a physical pressence in the upcoming chapter. He's talked about--at length--but he's not around. No sweeping into the courtroom and putting Lionel in his place or cashing in long-held favors to sway the custody hearing. Which ever of them (if either) decide to make the first move, they are going to need one heck of a push to do it at this point, given both their emotional states. Reviewer: memasuzy Signed Date: 2012.07.13 - 01:28AM Title: Chapter 22 I had to read this several times before reviewing, just to let it sink in. Harry made the decision to enlist in the task force and with that came the urge to settle his affairs. As soon as he concluded that was what he was doing, he told his closest friends (Ron/Hermione and then Bart/Nell) before going to see Ginny. He needed to settle all of his affairs and that included apoligizing to Ginny for what he said to her. The choice to enlist was something he struggled with off-screen. It was only chance that he decided on the night Ginny arrived in her new home. That's one of their main issues, the inability to properly fight. There's a healthy way to do it, as you can probably atest to, and how they do it isn't it. It was easy for Harry to imagine that the Snitch was an Immaculate Conception of some sort without a face or name to put to the birth father. Much like it's easy to believe the magic trick about sawing a woman in half so long as you ignore the fact that there's two people in the box. It in no way changes his feelings towards the baby, rather it's just making him question his own place in this whole mess. That, and the fact that Ginny lied outright when he asked her about the Snitch being Lionel's. I think it's one thing to know she was hiding information and it's another to know she wouldn't tell him the truth off of a direct question. No, Harry's task force will not go after Lionel. Reviewer: amanda212 Signed Date: 2012.07.12 - 11:47PM Title: Chapter 22 Great story, yet such a sad chapter = ( I can definitely see Harry wanting to walk away like that, but in the end he won't go through with it....right?? Us readers want a happy ending!! Also I was surprised that Ginny didn't go after him and tell him how she really feels. Perhaps she still harbors some resentment towards him for the things he said to her? Either way, they have a lot to work out. I think it was just the shock of hearing Harry tell her that all of these wonderful moments and feeling between them that had gotten Ginny through some difficult times lately hadn't been real to him. She accepted his apology for the things he called her, but she couldn't see past being hurt by his assertion to chase after him. Maine was beautiful, as always. Very restorative. This beloved writer will work to give her equally-beloved readers something new to gnaw on as soon as she can. Reviewer: brown_eyed_gurl87 Signed Date: 2012.07.12 - 09:45PM Title: Chapter 22 Wow! I've read your story and honestly have become addicted to it. I keep checking to see when the next chapter will be posted up. I have to admit though that right now I'm terribly upset with Harry. Don't get me wrong Ginny screwed up, she has her flaws but the things Harry said and his actions... leaving for eight years? Is he bloody mad? Like the hatter? Jeezh! I wish I could slap the chap! Lol. Honestly just goes to prove you're doing an amazing job writing your story because we care so much for the characters. I'm rooting for Ginny and a part of me does wish she somehow manages the impossible and disappears with the snitch, and that Harry mans up and get his head unstuck and realizes that leaving for 8 years will earn him no favors not benefit him. And well heck if Gin and Snitch disappear and he has to run around the country looking for them well serves him right ;) Reviewer: ginnyweasley777 Signed Date: 2012.07.12 - 09:24AM Title: Chapter 22 absolutly fantastic, so glad Ginny's not just giving up without a fight Reviewer: carolyn jinn Signed Date: 2012.07.12 - 05:05AM Title: Chapter 22
That's a very interesting viewpoint on Harry. He did say some pretty reprehensible things to her and he's not above putting other's needs over his own. We'll see. Lionel wouldn't have to call in as many favors as you think. Money=Power. Dresden Money=Nearly Aboslute Power. Ginny can't make a strong case against him being a bastard. Again, we'll see. Reviewer: dseay Signed Date: 2012.07.11 - 08:44AM Title: Chapter 22 Okay, not sure what to think now. Don't get me wrong, I still love your story and your writing style, you truly are amazing. I know you said that there life is not all rosy which is so true but these two have got a lot of work ahead of them. Both Ginny an dHarry are right and yet oh so wrong. I really do hope these two can find their way back together and am lookinhg forward to see how you can write that part because I am sure it will be amazing and just so sweet. Definately looking forward to the next chapter. Reviewer: redheadedfervor Signed Date: 2012.07.11 - 06:38AM Title: Chapter 22 While I am enjoying this story immensely, I have to admit that I am disappointed in Harry and Ginny's behavior. Now, I know emotions are running high between these two, and there is so much painful history that's it's incredibly hard for either of them to see straight. But, I really think that one of them needs to start pulling their head out of their ass, and fight FOR each other, and personally I think it needs to be Harry. Ginny, as much as I love her, is a mom now and with the whole Lionel factor in the mix, she's not capable fighting two emotional wars! Whenever Harry and Ginny talk they BOTH beat around the bush FAR too much, and I know that you're writing this story very realistically as that's what real people do in situations like these, HOWEVER, I am dying for Harry to say "Ginny I love you, I always have and I always will, But I want to know why you left me, I need an explanation! If I don't get one then I have to leave you behind! BUT FIRST I NEED TO KNOW IF YOU EVER LOVED ME!" And/Or Ginny to say "Harry I love you! I left you because I worried that I was interfering with your ability to live a life you your own. But dammit I have never stopped loving you, even when you called me a whore, and which really pisses me off! But, it doesn't stop me from wanting to raise this beautiful baby boy with you! Regardless of who his biological father is, in the Sitch's eyes, it's always been you!"AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! I don't think they're dialogue the next time they cross paths will be quite that bluntly worded. I love the sentiment behind it, don't get me wrong, it just isn't what I have in mind for them. I am writing a little bit a faster, I already have about 2,200 words done. However, I am going on a six day straight stretch at work so I don't know how that'll affect me. We're getting there, don't worry. Reviewer: JSM Signed Date: 2012.07.11 - 12:30AM Title: Chapter 22 My first thoughts upon reading this chapter (setting aside intense feelings of depression and despair, of course) was that while Harry and Ginny have taken steps forward in their understanding, they are still not able to deal with the emotions and consequences that they bring. Once again, both of them are ready to leave behind their lives to escape. I do not blame them at all, and I can't say I wouldn't do the same in their situations, but it isn't necessarily their best option. No, not the best option. Not at all, especially considering they made these decisions without consulting anyone. It's for your own good sometimes to take that step back and listen--actually listen--to someone else's opinion. Depending on how one particular section goes, I'm thinking no more than three chapters. They'll be long ones, though. We can cover a lot in chapters like that. I am insanely curious to hear your ideas, just to see if you're close to the mark. I can't promise to give you an answer, but I'd love PMs from anyone on where they think we're ending up. Reviewer: DebbieO Signed Date: 2012.07.10 - 10:28PM Title: Chapter 22 I usually go back and reread your chapters as you post them, but I can't do it this time. I read it when you first posted at FF.net and couldn't even comment when I finished. I had to let a few days go by to recover! This chapter hurt more than the last one and Harry and Ginny's relationship seems more horribly broken than ever. I don't understand why Ginny didn't at the very least take responsibility for the horrible things she had said back to Harry. She seemed to agree that they had been caught up in an illusion and there was nothing real to fight for. I made the analogy awhile back between their relationship and a house decimated by a natural disaster. Sometimes it has to be completely rebuilt from destruction to make it stronger.Wild guess here, but I think we've pretty well-covered destruction. It was her shock of hearing him say those things that silenced her. In a matter of a couple of weeks she went from having an in-everything-but-name family with Harry to having him tell her that none of it mattered b/c it wasn't real. I think it would take a lot for person to have the will to still fight in that scenario and Ginny just didn't have it in here at that moment. Please explain how fluff can be meaty. By it's very definition it has to be light and airy and delicate. No meat on that bone. I don't know how well I'd write straight-up fluff. I'd get bored with it quickly Is it wrong that when you mentioned sugar in your last line that the chorus of "Pour Some Sugar on Me" immediately started blaring in my head? Yes? Okay, moving on... Reviewer: Birlan Signed Date: 2012.07.10 - 10:21PM Title: Chapter 22 I suspect like always I will have a minority opinion on this chapter. I thought it showed some really important steps forward. I think your characters had to have some really unpleasant experiences and confront some truths to move ahead. I think she had sidestepped that issue. She knew she had lied to him and was continuing to lie, but she didn't equate that with betrayl until the talk with Sapien. Everything that Ginny had sort of built around herself--all of her perceptions about herself and Harry--have fallen away and now with the prospect of leaving with the baby, Ginny feels a sense of needing to make Harry understand why she ended up with Lionel in the first place. It even startles her a little when she examines the depth she was trying to both punish herself while forcing herself to feel something after the break-up. She's seeing how out of control she had been and to say that it was news to Harry was an understatement. I think she would have gone into a further apology had she been given time to. Ginny was trying to formulate some kind of response when Harry changed it to the custody case which changed to him leaving. There wasn't a moment for her to do it then, in her shock at what was happening. Everything that Harry let slide off his back or outright ignored was leading to the last chapter's explosion. I thought it would pack more punch to have a huge, earth-shattering confrontation as opposed to a series of little ones and I thought that Harry's personality fit with someone who wouldn't rush into a fight. He would do everything he could to avoid one, especially with Ginny. There was never an intent to make it seem like her mistakes didn't affect him. They did, deeply as we now know. You know, Harry's getting all the legal information from Hermione, someone who believes in the law and in the idea of justice for the underdog (see S.P.E.W.) Maybe she sees more hope in the situation than the others or maybe she's just painting a rosy picture for Harry so he doesn't end up in actual legal trouble for trying to kill Lionel. ****SPOILER**** In any event, I can promise right here and now that Harry will not be present physically in the next chapter. Make of that what you will. | |||||||
|